Fuel Follow-up: Maybe Additives Have a Place

Nov. 25, 2014

My last posting was a description of numerous fuel-related issues experienced by many fleets. I sparked some strong debate from a few responders who I respect. The intent of the article was to explore fuel-related issues many fleets suffer from in the deep chill of winter. Most want to use fuel gelling of fuel as the excuse to explain the $1000 tow bill on the invoice and the rent for the service bay to thaw out the vehicle, or to explain a late load to a mad customer threatening to switch carriers and deflect the HEAT from the bosses.

Most of those replies addressed my discussion about blending of kerosene below a certain temperature, and my observation that northern US and Canada seem to have their formulas together. I believe that somehow they have figured out how to operate trucks in the deep freeze. I didn’t mean to imply we in the US don’t know how to do that, but rather that there are many fleets that do need to know what to do and to stop using GELLING as the excuse.

Here’s the eloquent comment from the Additive Guy on my original post:

Third, there is NEVER "... a point you need kerosene." Kerosene has less BTU (heat energy) Content so it will result in significantly less fuel economy/MPG mileage, it is very dry so it does not lubricate the fuel system adequately and it is much more expensive than diesel fuel.
PLUS, kerosene blending in today's diesel fuels is not like it used to be. In fact, our lab testing of four typical diesel fuels indicates the fuel CFPP (Cold Filter Plugging Point - the temperature at which a fuel filter is likely to plug up because of paraffin wax) will only be lowered by 0 to 3 degrees F with 10% kerosene, 5 to 6 degrees F with 20% kerosene and 7 to 11 degrees F with 30% kerosene blends. These CFPP reductions will NOT materially improve the engine operability in cold weather (and the cost to blend those percentages of kerosene will be large.

In Summary

The intend of my article was not a strike against additives. But those who know me know I am not an additive guy. I know that at some point additives do work to a certain degree and that USLD fuel is much different than the 500 ppm diesel sulfated fuel we used to use. That change in the chemical makeup has altered how we manage fuel and keep trucks on the road during these spells of arctic cool downs.  Although I do agree to a point with the above comments and certainly have respect for the writer, I have yet to see any fuel additive company step up to the plate and pay for all the costs that go along with the fuel related breakdowns the additive advertisements say they are supposed to prevent. Maybe they do work at the temperature stated, but 11 degrees lower and 30% kero in my opinion is the safest play. As a fleet manager I would be willing to convert my positions of the term snake oil liquids if any additive company wants to back their products with the green, and that isn’t ALGAE.

The fact is I have not experienced the pour point claims of the fuel companies’ pour point testing, nor shared the fleets’ pains. That’s why I suggest paying the price for success and on time deliveries despite lower fuel economy.

 The intent of my article was for the readers to look deeper into what is really the cause of their winter fuel problems. GELLING is the easiest answer to accept, but it is not acceptable. The problem is often maintenance of the truck or the fuel itself. It is the wax or ice crystals, and seldom if at all GELLING.

Thank you for the responses. It brings another level of awareness to the problem.   I have never seen a presentation or discussion as deep as this at TMC. That’s something we need to do.

About the Author

Darry Stuart | President

Darry Stuart has more than 45 years of experience in the transportation industry. As President/ CEO of DWS Fleet Management Services, he has been providing “Limited Time Executive" services in transportation and fleet equipment management to a variety of companies.

An ASE-certified master technician, Stuart began his career on the shop floor before moving on to fleet management executive positions at Perdue Chicken, BFI (Browning-Ferris Industries), United Truck Leasing, the  Keen  Companies, and Cumberland Farms/Gulf Oil.

For 35 years, Stuart has been an active member of the Technology & Maintenance Council (TMC) of the American Trucking Assns., serving as the group’s general chairman from 2007-2008. He is the recipient of numerous industry awards, including TMC's Silver Spark Plug, which is given in recognition of an individual's outstanding contributions to the cause of excellence in heavy-duty vehicle maintenance management. He has been cited as an industry expert or authored over  250 articles on equipment and fleet management topics.

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!

Sponsored Recommendations

The Future of Mirrors is Closer Than it Appears

Why Mirror Camera Systems are the next step for fleet safety and exoneration While many commercial trucking cameras are similarly marketed, they are not all created equally. The...

The 20:1 Solution: Unlocking the ROI of a Modern Asset Maintenance Solution

Discover how modern fleet maintenance software can drive step-change improvements in shop efficiency, cost control and vehicle productivity, along with how to calculate the ROI...

Digital and AI Solutions for Rideshare Safety

Anyline’s study, “How Digital AI Solutions Can Enhance Rideshare Safety,” reveals rideshare drivers are overly confident in their tire knowledge, risking passenger safety. Download...

Introducing the World’s First Mobile Tire Tread Scanner

Anyline’s innovation allows accurate tire tread measurement via any mobile device, ensuring legal compliance for fleets. Read more and find out how you can cut operating costs...