Law firm claims quietness of hybrids poses risk

Dec. 1, 2009
Steven J. Schwartzapfel, a partner in the New York personal injury firm of Schwartzapfel Truhowsky Marcus P.C. is putting auto and truck OEMs on notice that the of hybrid cars and trucks can be considered a higher safety risk for pedestrians and bicycle riders than gasoline- or diesel-only powered vehicles. These vehicles may provide important environmental benefits, but they cannot do so at the expense

Steven J. Schwartzapfel, a partner in the New York personal injury firm of Schwartzapfel Truhowsky Marcus P.C. is putting auto and truck OEMs on notice that the “quietness” of hybrid cars and trucks can be considered a higher safety risk for pedestrians and bicycle riders than gasoline- or diesel-only powered vehicles.

“These vehicles may provide important environmental benefits, but they cannot do so at the expense of safety,” he said, pointing to a September 2009 report by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) that found hybrid vehicles, which are typically quieter than internal combustion engine cars and trucks, can pose a greater risk to pedestrians and bicyclists.

NHTSA's study determined that hybrid electric vehicles have a higher incidence rate of pedestrian and bicyclist crashes than do models powered by internal combustion engine alone in certain vehicle maneuvers, and that these results should serve as a guide when designing future HEV/pedestrian and bicyclist crash prevention programs.

“In light of this report, hybrid manufacturers and drivers are now on notice that they need to take steps to make sure their cars are seen and heard by cyclists and pedestrians,” said Schwartzapfel. “They may be held accountable for injuries when they fail to take those steps.”

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!

Sponsored Recommendations

What challenges are top of mind for fleet professionals in 2025? Get exclusive insights from the 2025 Fleet Trends Survey and discover where the industry is headed next.
The most successful fleets accomplish more than delivering freight. To accomplish this, fleets need a fuel that’s reliable, more economical and more sustainable. That fuel is ...
Are your KPIs driving real fleet improvement? Learn how to set smarter, data-driven benchmarks, track success like top-performing fleets, and apply proven strategies to optimize...
Learn how eets can enhance truck utilization and minimize safety incidents using business intelligence and AI. Delve into innovative practices, technology integration and real...