Fleetowner 5992 Checking4
Fleetowner 5992 Checking4
Fleetowner 5992 Checking4
Fleetowner 5992 Checking4
Fleetowner 5992 Checking4

Coalition: Safety fitness ratings revamp ‘flouts’ will of Congress

Jan. 13, 2016
Roadside data flawed, unfair to small carriers, group says

A pending rulemaking that is expected to incorporate roadside inspection data and computer calculations to determine a carrier’s safety fitness rating violates congressionally mandated regulatory reforms and disregards specific provisions of the FAST Act, according to an ad hoc coalition of small-business associations.

In a letter to several senators and representatives who have supported reform of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) and its Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) trucking safety scoring system, the groups contend the Safety Fitness Determination (SFD) rulemaking will continue to use much of the same data that Congress wants reviewed.  

“A ‘quickie’ rulemaking on SFD criteria, in which any aspects of the agency’s flawed SMS methodology would be treated as a given and small-business impacts would be ignored, is patently not what Congress intended in the FAST Act,” says the letter from the coalition, which includes the National Association of Small Trucking Companies, the Western State Trucking Association, Alliance for Safe, Efficient and Competitive Truck Transportation and others.

Several members of the coalition have fought CSA since its launch in 2010, having successfully argued in court for clarifications to be made to the FMCSA website and, most recently, in Congress to have public display of trucking company safety rankings removed entirely.

Though the SFD rule has not been published, the letter cites violations of new rulemaking procedures put in place by the recently passed highway bill, as well as the known “statistical defects” and the disparate impact of roadside data on small carriers.

Most essentially, “any safety fitness determination based upon roadside compliance data and crash statistics developed for use in SMS/CSA methodology” is precluded the FAST Act, says the letter.

FMCSA Acting Administrator Scott Darling said earlier this week the agency expects to publish the rule sometime in January.

Speaking to Fleet Owner with regard to the agency’s 2016 regulatory agenda, Bill Quade, FMCSA associate administrator of enforcement, explained that the agency is working to complete the data verification steps that Congress wants.

The reforms called for in the highway bill, similarly, will not impact the Safety Fitness Determination proposed rule. Quade emphasized that the SMS scores within the CSA system are “relative,” as carriers are ranked among comparable fleets and operations. In the pending fitness rule, “absolute standards” will be used to rate carriers. Additionally, the “data sufficiency concerns” that will be “less relevant.”

“We’re going to get comments on it, and our hope is that we can move forward with a new system to rate [carriers] for their recent on-the-road performance,” Quade said.

About the Author

Kevin Jones 1 | Editor

Kevin Jones has an odd fascination with the supply chain. As editor of American Trucker, he focuses on the critical role owner-ops and small fleets play in the economy, locally and globally. And he likes big trucks.

Sponsored Recommendations

Stop Sweating Temperature Excursions

Advanced chemical indicators give you the peace of mind that comes from reliable insights into your supply chains. Compromised shipments can be identified the moment they arrive...

How Electric Vehicles Help You Prolong the Life of Your Fleet

Before adopting electric vehicles for commercial/government fleets, prioritize cost inquiries. Maintenance is essential; understand the upkeep of EV fleets. Here’s what you need...

How to Choose the Right Route Planning Solution

This free buyer's guide will help equip you with the knowledge and insights needed to analyze route planning software and vendors in the market and, ultimately, make an informed...

How to Put Your Trucking Data to Work

How fleets can overcome data overload to optimize operations and get ahead.

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!