Gotcha! Cameras slow rate of red-light violations

A new study found that the installation of the devices led to fewer people driving through red lights at intersections.

A study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) reviewing the use of red-light cameras at four major intersections within the county of Arlington, VA, over a two-year period determined that those cameras significantly reduced the number of red-light violations – proving, in the eyes of the group’s researchers, that such technology can successfully “modify” driver behavior.

Anne McCartt, senior vice president for research at IIHS and the study’s lead author, said that one year after the start of ticketing in July 2010, the odds of a red light running violation at those four camera-covered intersections dropped across the board.

She said violations occurring at least 0.5 seconds after the light turned red were 39% less likely than would have been expected without cameras, with violations occurring at least 1 second after were 48% less likely, while the odds of a violation occurring at least 1.5 seconds into the red phase fell 86%.

“The study provides fresh evidence that automated enforcement can get drivers to modify their behavior,” McCartt noted. “What these numbers show is that those violations most likely to lead to a crash are reduced the most. The longer the light has been red when a violator enters an intersection, the more likely the driver is to encounter a vehicle traveling in another direction or a pedestrian.”

To calculate how the cameras affected violation rates, IIHS researchers videotaped traffic a month after ticketing began and again after a year.

In addition to the four camera-enforced intersections, videotaping was done at four other intersections in Arlington — two on the same corridors where cameras were located and two elsewhere — to see if there was any spillover effect from the cameras, while four control intersections in neighboring Fairfax County, which does not have a camera program, also were observed.

“The Arlington program is another example of the safety benefits cameras bring to intersections,” said David Kelly, executive director of the National Coalition for Safer Roads (NCSR) and former acting administrator for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), told Fleet Owner.

“Red-light runners don’t discriminate who they hit,” he explained. “Commercial drivers are at as much risk as everyone else on the roads. We have to make sure that we are doing everything we can to get drivers to slow down at intersections and obey the light.”

Kelly pointed out that, due to their size, it is harder for commercial vehicles to stop short or perform evasive maneuvers to avoid a crash. “This makes them particularly susceptible during intersection crashes,” he stressed, why is why red-light cameras can benefit carrier safety.

IIHS added that the number of U.S. communities currently using red-light cameras have grown to about 540, with a 2011 study by the group of large cities with longstanding red-light cameras finding that cameras reduced the fatal red-light running crash rate by 24% and the rate of all types of fatal crashes at signalized intersections by 17%.

Discuss this Article 4

MNDriver
on Jan 28, 2013

How about a report on the number of rear end collisions at this same intersection.

DavidMac
on Jan 28, 2013

I wonder what the relationship is between IIHS and the manufacturer of red-light cameras? How much stock does David Kelly, National Coalition for Safer Roads, own in those red-light manufacturers? Since the death of journalism in 2007, the public will probably never know. Only private citizens with sufficiently deep pockets can afford the research to uncover the truth.

ssgintx
on Jan 29, 2013

Red light cameras are for revenue for the cities that have them. Kids with paintball guns drive the maintenance dept nuts.

ProDriver
on Feb 7, 2013

I can certainly understand the degrading remarks, and skepticism, however I also understand that the vast majority of Americans are terribly under educated on the topic of driving without actually knowing it, You'd think a developed country that is so involved currently in gun control topics, would recognize that more people die each year from cars and understand that something needs to be done. Sadly the average motorst is simply oblivious to the fact that 40% of all collisions each year occur in intersections and that they are 2nd in severity only to a head on crash, so I expect the comments like the ones above. That same topic ignorance is what prevents us from saving more people. Cars don't kill people just like guns don't. People kill people through their own careless acts and omissions.

The comment about rear end collisions at photo enforced intersections, while certainly an interesting statistic, it in no way reduces the advantages of the camera's, but rather reflects the larger issue of Americans thinking they can drive they way they want and tailgate. That's another issue that must be dealt with. Anyone knowledgeable about defensive driving techiniques knows that what lies ahead of a vehcile is always priority 1. What is to either side is priority 2, and what's behind is priority 3. They must be dealt with in that order. Even if rear end collisions were higher it would not be an equal offset to side impacts which result in far more injuries and deaths than rear end collisions which are usually no where as severe as a side impact. It's about simple physics.

As for the revenue comment, I could not care less about anything more than how much money they make. If they save the life of a friend, family member or my own, make them $1,000 a piece, so the complainers can really complain about something. I understand that the common mortorist would need to become a victim before also becoming an advocate. It's simply human nature. Like MADD, wouldn't it have been great to be an advocate before you lost a family member to a drunk driver? I suppose there are those who think that's a jadded cause as well and will post so here. Maybe the Zombies really are coming....

Please or Register to post comments.

Newsletter Signup

Search 2.5+ million listings

Buyer's Guide

Connect With Us